Dispute breaks out in Kent court as man pleads not guilty to West Hill shooting death

A dispute broke out in court on Monday in Kent among friends and relatives of two men involved in the June 11 West Hill shooting death.

Christopher Hutton enters a not guilty plea on Monday in Kent to first-degree murder in connection with the June 11 West Hill shooting death of JaeBrione Gary.

Christopher Hutton enters a not guilty plea on Monday in Kent to first-degree murder in connection with the June 11 West Hill shooting death of JaeBrione Gary.

A dispute broke out in court on Monday in Kent among friends and relatives of two men involved in the June 11 West Hill shooting death.

Christopher I. Hutton, 42, entered a not guilty plea to first-degree murder at the arraignment in King County Superior Court at the Maleng Regional Justice Center. King County prosecutors claim Hutton shot and killed JaeBrione Gary, 22, at an apartment reportedly to avenge some type of earlier robbery of Hutton by Gary.

More than a dozen of Gary’s friends and family members attended the arraignment. Several of Hutton’s family and friends also were present. Before the arraignment, a dispute broke out between the two parties. After several minutes, corrections officers calmed both parties so court could resume. Following the arraignment, another scuffle broke out in the hallway outside the courtroom.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

Hutton’s attorney made a motion asking Judge Patrick Oishi to prevent the media from photographing Hutton’s face, citing a “fear of retaliation.” Oishi denied the motion, allowing photographs to be taken.

Hutton remains in the county jail in Kent with bail set at $1 million. Hutton, whose last known address was a Federal Way hotel, is scheduled to return to court on July 13 when a trial date could be set or attorneys could ask for more time to prepare the case.

According to charging papers, Hutton reportedly pistol whipped Gary and shot him three times at close range while chasing the unarmed Gary through an apartment in the 2700 block of South 256th Place.

Witness descriptions at the apartment complex of the suspect led a Kent Police officer to immediately recognize the description as being Hutton. The officer has worked for several years in the area of the shooting and had seen Hutton parked at the apartment complex in recent months in a late 1990s Cadillac El Dorado. Police had the license plate of the car and put out an all-points bulletin about Hutton and his vehicle.

Renton Police spotted the Cadillac shortly after the shooting and stopped Hutton in the 10500 block of Southeast Carr Road. He was taken into custody without incident.

Kent Police obtained a search warrant for the Cadillac and found in the trunk a chrome-color revolver wrapped in a wash rag inside a plastic grocery bag. The gun appeared to have a blood smear on it.

During an interview with detectives, Hutton denied any knowledge of the shooting of Gary and claimed he hadn’t been in that area in the previous three days. He also denied he had any guns in his car. He told detectives he had watched the NBA playoffs that night and then went to visit his wife’s residence in Renton. He said he was driving back to his Federal Way hotel when Renton Police stopped him.

Hutton has several criminal convictions, including two counts of first-degree promoting prostitution in 2007 in Kent, where he lived in an apartment. He used girls younger than 18 while running a prostitution ring.

Gary and Hutton had reportedly known each other for a number of years. An aunt of Gary told detectives that she had dated Hutton many years ago.

This marked the second time in three years that Gary had been shot. Gary testified in 2012 against a Seattle gang member who shot and wounded him outside of a South Seattle restaurant.

Reporter Steve Hunter contributed to this article.

 

 


Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@kentreporter.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.kentreporter.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in News

t
Future female firefighters learn key skills at workshop

32 women participate in firefighting, emergency medical services training

t
Kent pedestrian killed in April 21 crash identified

Vicente Islas Gomez, 50, died of multiple blunt force injuries along Central Avenue South

Courtesy File Photo, WSDOT
Section of State Route 167 in Kent to be fully closed night of April 24

From 10 p.m. Thursday, April 24 to 4 a.m. Friday, April 25 between S. 180th Street and S. 212th Street

t
Kent man wanted in DV incident reportedly ‘has left the area’

Avon Cobb still on the run; flashbang device might have caused fire at Auburn business where he fled

Courtesy Photo, Comcast
Some Comcast, Xfinity Business customers lose service in Kent

Vandals damage cable line; service expected to be restored by 4 p.m. Tuesday, April 22

The city of Kent Corrections Facility, 1230 Central Ave. S. COURTESY PHOTO, City of Kent
Female inmate, 45, dies while in custody at city of Kent jail

Found unresponsive Tuesday morning, April 22

t
Kent male pedestrian, 45, struck and killed by vehicle

Man was crossing Monday night, April 21 in the 900 block of Central Avenue South

t
WSDOT plans nighttime lane closures in Kent on I-5, SR 516

April 21-27: Northbound I-5, certain directions of SR 516

t
Kent Police to host prescription drug take back day

Drop off medicines from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m Saturday, April 26 outside of Kent Police Department

t
33rd Legislative District sets Telephone Town Hall for April 29

District includes part of Kent; call hosted by Sen. Orwall and State Reps. Gregerson and Obras

Kent Police officers will carry the latest Taser 10 model produced by Axon Enterprises. The gun can fire more shots and at a longer distance than the older model. COURTESY PHOTO, Axon Enterprises
Kent Police add latest Taser model to officers’ equipment

Taser 10 can shoot more shots at a longer distance; department also adds dash cameras

t
Kent crime numbers drop dramatically in first quarter of 2025

All categories down compared to first three months of 2024; commercial burglaries drop 62%