Kent School Board members Meghin Margel, Awale Farah and Tim Clark face a civil lawsuit along with Superintendent Israel Vela over the board’s formation of a Labor Policy Committee. COURTESY PHOTO, Kent School District

Kent School Board members Meghin Margel, Awale Farah and Tim Clark face a civil lawsuit along with Superintendent Israel Vela over the board’s formation of a Labor Policy Committee. COURTESY PHOTO, Kent School District

Judge denies preliminary injunction in Kent School District civil case

Lawsuit still moves forward in efforts to stop exclusion of Board Director Cook from labor committee

A King County Superior Court judge denied a preliminary injunction motion in a civil lawsuit filed against the Kent School District, three Kent School Board members and the superintendent.

Plaintiffs Greta Nelson, a district resident and parent, and Donald Cook, a school board member, had hoped to put a temporary stop to the the board’s resolution that kept Cook off a newly formed Labor Policy Committee that deals with contracts with teachers, bus drivers, officer workers and others, because his wife teaches in the district.

Judge Nicholas Straley ruled Thursday, June 27 in a Seattle courtroom that Nelson and Cook failed to show the three things needed for a temporary injunction: a substantial likelihood on the success of the merits, a well-grounded fear of invasion of their personal rights and irreparable harm.

Straley said one reason for his denial is no labor contracts are currently being negotiated or coming up later this year. The Kent Education Association (teachers union) ratified a new agreement June 26 (just one day prior to the court hearing) and the Teamsters Local Union 763 (bus drivers) also reached an agreement.

“Those are the only two contracts that have come up recently,” Straley said. “To the extent that there may be negotiations that go forward in the future (2025), the plaintiffs may be able to renew their motion if they believe if Mr. Cook is not able to participate in the Labor Policy Committee it will have an impact at that time. But at this time, the court does not believe that there’s been a showing of irreparable harm required for the court to intervene.”

Despite the setback, Nelson remains confident in the case filed against the district, Superintendent Israel Vela and board members Meghin Margel, Awale Farah and Tim Clark.

“Yesterday’s loss—is not a loss,” Nelson posted June 28 on social media. “The litigation process can be frustrating, especially to those that don’t understand how it works. At the hearing, plaintiffs were not successful in obtaining a preliminary injunction that would have suspended Resolution 1669 temporarily and preliminarily, while the case plays out in court as a matter of course prior to the assigned trial date of March 31, 2025.

“The judge had a very big task—which is to decide whether or not plaintiffs had met their burden of proof regarding whether or not irreparable harm had occurred by Resolution 1669—meaning that the “harm” cannot be remedied by any amount of money or repaired through legal means.”

Cook responded in court to the judge after he denied the motion.

“My concern with that is the irreparable harm is both to my reputation as an elected official and also to the fact that this continuing allows them to use this resolution to direct the superintendent and others to make this happen however they see fit,” Cook said.

Cook added that his duty as a board member will continue to be hindered if he’s not allowed to be involved in labor negotiations.

Judge Straley responded that although he denied the motion, the case continues.

“I’ve made my ruling in denying the motion, but the case has not been dismissed,” Straley said. “It will continue to go forward like any civil case at this time. There are steps that the parties can take with respect to how the case moves forward.”

Nelson took that as good news.

“While plaintiffs were not successful at this hearing in obtaining the temporary result they asked for, they were successful in learning what, specifically, is required to be included in their amended complaints—so that they can amend their complaints prior to the deadline for amending claims, and then arrange for process service on the defendants, which then requires the defendants to respond, in writing, within 20 days, to the complaint(s),” Nelson said.

Nelson said this particular requirement of the litigation process has not occurred yet because of strategic reasons, and also because of the lack of a law firm and support staff backing, as Nelson and Cook are handling the case on their own without attorneys.

Stephen DeJulio, an attorney with the Seattle law firm of Foster Garvey, represented the school district at the hearing, and started off with filing a declaration with the court from Vela that the only two labor contracts under consideration by the district had been wrapped up.

“There’s no harm to the plaintiff currently because there’s no committee meetings, there’s no negotiations,” DeJulio said.

DeJulio also addressed the reasons for forming the Labor Policy Committee after Judge Straley asked about the impact of Cook’s marriage to a district teacher who could benefit from the information.

“Both the impact that may occur in respect to the strategy for the board negotiating with the Kent Education Association but also the impact of perceived favoritism for teachers with respect to dealing with other unions, seven or eight unions,” DeJulio said.

Cook has said since he was elected last year he would recuse himself from voting or talks about the teachers union contract. But Cook and Nelson said he should be allowed to participate in other labor group negotiations, which is the basis of their suit.


Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@kentreporter.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.kentreporter.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in News

Courtesy Photo, King County
Prolific tagger faces charges for damage to Kent water tower

Man one of dozens who reportedly tagged properties across King County, including West Hill tower

t
Federal Way man charged in Kent I-5 crash that killed passenger

Documents state that evidence reportedly showed he was the driver, but he blamed the passenger.

The Kent Police Department went all out with their “Moana” themed display - even Maui showed up. Photo by Bailey Jo Josie/Sound Publishing.
The Hogwarts Express pulls into Battle of the Badges | Photos

The 2024 Battle of the Badges took over the Renton Technical College on Dec. 14.

Kent Police Chief Rafael Padilla. COURTESY PHOTO, Kent Police
City of Kent crime numbers drop in 2024 compared to 2023

Vehicle thefts, commercial burglaries and robberies see big decreases

Courtesy Photo, Kent School District
Kent School District says it ‘will do better next time’ with school closures

Late notifications issued about closures after Dec. 18 windstorm

t
Kent Police arrest pair for downtown robbery of pedestrian

Reportedly used pepper spray to attack Kent man, 56, as he walked on sidewalk Dec. 16

Meeker Middle School, one of six schools closed Wednesday, Dec. 18 in the Kent School District due to power outages from a windstorm. COURTESY PHOTO, Kent School District
Windstorm causes closure of six Kent schools due to power outages

Four elementary, two middle schools closed Wednesday, Dec. 18; couple of city roads closed

Volunteers wrap gifts during the 2023 Toys for Joy program. COURTESY PHOTO, Puget Sound Fire
Puget Sound Fire puts out plea for more Toys for Joy donations

Toys needed for children ages 9 to 12; more bikes, scooters requested; deadline is Dec. 20

t
Kent man, 19, faces multiple charges after pursuit near Wenatchee

Driver reportedly fails to stop for state trooper, crashes stolen vehicle along State Route 97

Kent School District Board Director Awale Farah, left, and Superintendent Israel Vela at a high school graduation last summer. COURTESY PHOTO, Kent School District
Awale Farah resigns immediately from Kent School Board

Says because of ‘family commitments’ he cannot fulfill rest of his term that expires in November 2025

t
Kent’s Lower Russell Levee project receives John Spellman Award

City, King County Flood District and other partners recognized for historic preservation

Northwood Middle School, 17007 SE 184th St., in unincorporated part of King County in Renton and part of the Kent School District. COURTESY PHOTO, Kent School District
Calls about man trying to access Northwood Middle School causes lockdown

Deputies arrest man for investigation of resisting arrest, obstruction at Kent School District property