Washington’s ‘death penalty’: justice or revenge? Legislature tackles divisive issue; conclusion elusive

Is Washington State's death penalty for capital crimes justice or revenge? HB 1504, heard before the Judiciary Committee March 6, would eliminate the death penalty in this state and replace it with lifetime incarceration. The bill will not likely move forward this session as the last day to hear bills in their chamber of origin is March 13.

  • BY Wire Service
  • Tuesday, March 12, 2013 4:43pm
  • News
Rep. Reuven Carlyle

Rep. Reuven Carlyle

By Kylee Zabel
WNPA Olympia News Bureau

Is Washington State’s death penalty for capital crimes justice or revenge?

HB 1504, heard before the Judiciary Committee March 6, would eliminate the death penalty in this state and replace it with lifetime incarceration. The bill will not likely move forward this session as the last day to hear bills in their chamber of origin is March 13.

Sponsor of the legislation, Rep. Reuven Carlyle (D-Seattle), said during public testimony Wednesday on the measure that he hoped his bill would spark necessary dialogue on this often divisive issue.

“I do not seek to argue,” he said. “But I ask for the public conversation to be real, to be genuine and reflective.”

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

All 17 persons registering to testify endorsed the bill, citing the high costs of capital punishment cases, past wrongful convictions and the believed failure of the death penalty to deter violent crimes.

Rep. Maureen Walsh (R-Walla Walla), the only Republican co-sponsoring the draft legislation, said that in addition to the costs and lack of evidence that suggests the death penalty is a deterrent, she supports the measure because execution lets convicted murderers off too easy.

“I’d rather they sit in jail the rest of their lives, think about what they’ve done, live in that hell for the rest of their lives,” she said. “It’s just way too easy to kill them and be done with it.”

According to a letter written by former Gov. Dan Evans, the primary reason victims’ families support the death penalty is out of a desire for revenge, a sentiment to which Walsh agrees.

“If the death penalty is no deterrent, is enormously costly and is riddled with errors, all that is left is revenge,” wrote Evans.

However, Rep. Steve O’Ban (R-University Place) argued that prosecutors seek the death penalty not out of a yearning for revenge but due to an innate desire for justice.

“This notion that there’s something evil or wrong or barbaric or some ancient desire for revenge, I think, diminishes them and diminishes what is really at stake when someone is seeking justice on behalf of their loved one who can no longer speak for themselves,” said O’Ban.

Several family members of murder victims and religion leaders testified in support of HB 1504, claiming the “eye for an eye” mentality places more focus on the murderer and detracts from the real tragedy and the loss of innocent victims.

‘Perpetuates a climate of violence’

John Rosenberg, pastor at The Lutheran Church of the Good Shepherd in Olympia and representing Faith Action Network, said that continued use of the death penalty “perpetuates a climate of violence.”

The taking of one life to compensate for the loss of another corrupts morality, Rosenberg asserted.

Committee members also voiced concerns about the high costs of these cases compared to non-capital trials.

The initial cost of a capital case is not what inflates the price alone. It is the lengthy appeals process. For example, the 1982 State v. Campbell case cost taxpayers and the state more than $2.3 million as Campbell filed three federal appeals from 1982 to 1991 during his stay-of-execution granted by the federal Ninth Circuit Court. However, the total cost has not yet been calculated as the previous figure does not take into account jail personnel, court and law enforcement salaries, costs accrued by the Attorney General’s office and Campbell’s attorney fees. Walsh said the case cost upward of $4 million altogether.

Costs of incarceration play little to no factor in the difference in increased costs. Regardless of the crime convicted, the average daily cost of incarceration, according to the Department of Corrections, is $90 and a combination of the initial trial, conviction and appeals process for capital cases can take about 20 years.

Rep. Jay Rodne (R-North Bend) said specifically that the costly price tags of these cases are due to precedents established by rulings of the courts based off of arguments made by a politically motivated criminal defense bar.

“What (the criminal defense bar) has done is deliberately increased the costs to counties to prosecute death penalty cases and then come to the Legislature and say ‘look, the costs of these cases are so much that we just ought to abolish the death penalty,'” he said.

“The larger political agenda,” he added, “is consistent with the left’s view that criminal justice should be always to expand criminals’ rights at the expense of law and order and at the expense of victims’ rights.”

The constitutional right to appeal one’s death penalty conviction in Washington is one cost driver for these types of cases. Mark Larranaga of the Safe and Just Alternatives campaign to end capital punishment also cited an extended jury selection process, additional investigation into a defendant’s past and that many cases serve indigent perpetrators as other potential costs.

But Larranaga charged that comments such as Rodne’s are uneducated as many of the costs associated with capital punishment cases are inherent due to precedent and constitutional requirements and cannot be avoided.

On average, capital cases cost half a million dollars more at the trial level compared to non-capital cases, according to a 2006 report from the Washington State Bar Association. Other costs associated with the appellate process and personal restraint petitions also increase costs as the case is further considered.

“We’re throwing millions and millions of dollars away that should be earmarked for more important things,” said Larranaga.

One of the eight death penalty cases in Washington is still pending, even though the defendant was convicted 18 years ago.

“You’ve proved my point,” Rodne said in response to Larranaga’s run-down of the cases’ cost barriers.”These are sympathetic jurists who have interpreted the constitution as to what’s required in the capital case, undoubtedly based on arguments made by the defense bar.”

“It’s incredulous to suggest that there is not a larger political agenda of the defense bar on this issue,” he added.

The only way to sidestep these burdensome costs is to eliminate the death penalty, challenged Larranaga.

Currently 17 states and the District of Columbia have abolished the death penalty with Maryland potentially on its way to become the eighteenth. On Wednesday, the Maryland Senate voted 27 to 20 to repeal the death penalty. The measure now awaits a vote from the House of Delegates.

Final committee action has not yet been scheduled for the Washington bill this session. A companion bill was introduced in the Senate by Sen. Adam Kline (D-Seattle), but did not gain traction this session.


Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@kentreporter.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.kentreporter.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in News

File Photo
Kent City Council approves Stay Out of Drug Areas zone

Nine organizations signed letter opposing new ordinance as ‘not an effective option’

t
Slower is safer: Steps to increase traffic safety in South King County

11-mile corridor has a high number of collisions, many of them fatal.

t
Family starts GoFundMe page for Kent man killed in crash

Jose Ortiz, 55, died in March 28 collision; wife suffered serious injuries; police arrest driver of 2nd vehicle

Courtesy Photo, City of Kent Parks
Kent city leaders want bigger piece of county Parks Levy

Measure could go to voters in August; King County Council to consider levy this month

King County Correctional Facility in Seattle. COURTESY PHOTO, King County
Man, 22, gets 20-year prison sentence for 2022 Kent killing

Drive-by shooting outside bar on Central Avenue took the life of 29-year-old Kent man

File Photo
Kent Police arrest man, 22, for arson, assaults against girlfriend

Allegedly set apartment on fire and repeatedly beat 19-year-old woman

t
Kent man, 56, dies in two-vehicle crash March 28 in Kent

Police arrest woman for investigation of vehicular homicide; collision at 94th Ave. S./S. 240th St.

File Photo, Kent Reporter
6-year-old boy drowns in pond on Kent’s East Hill

Child reportedly had autism and was drawn to the water on March 25, according to police

Valley Medical Center in Renton. Photo by Bailey Jo Josie/Sound Publishing.
Layoffs at Valley Medical Center stem from loss of funding

101 nonunion employees were fired March 25 from Renton hospital that also serves Kent.

t
FBI honors teen girls who helped stop abduction in Kent

They rescued 6-year-old girl from man in July 2024 in parking lot of apartment complex

t
Kent Police Blotter: March 11-23

Incidents include naked female, robbery with a syringe, assault, harassment

Kent Mayor Dana Ralph, fourth from left, stands with the Kent City Council, from left to right, John Boyd, Toni Troutner, Zandria Michaud, Satwinder Kaur, Brenda Fincher, Marli Larimer and Bill Boyce. COURTESY PHOTO, City of Kent
Cost-of-living pay hikes approved for Kent mayor, City Council

A 3.6% increase boosts mayor’s annual salary to $219,720; part-time council members to earn $37,296 per year