Two people were transported by helicopter after a three-vehicle crash Oct. 13 on State Route 410 near Enumclaw. Two people died at the scene. COURTESY PHOTO, Puget Sound Fire

Two people were transported by helicopter after a three-vehicle crash Oct. 13 on State Route 410 near Enumclaw. Two people died at the scene. COURTESY PHOTO, Puget Sound Fire

Enumclaw woman, 63, charged after deadly SR 410 crash

Michelle Oster has been charged with two counts of vehicular homicide and two counts of vehicular assault.

Charges have been filed against Enumclaw resident Michelle Oster, 63, for allegedly causing the Sunday, Oct. 13 fatal three-car wreck on state Route 410.

Oster, who also goes by the last name Thomas, was officially charged with two counts of vehicular homicide and two counts of vehicular assault on Oct. 16.

According to King County Superior Court and police documents, first responders received a call to a three-car crash around 11:28 a.m.

Initial witnesses told Washington State Patrol that Oster attempted to pass multiple vehicles while driving west on the highway by merging into the eastbound lane in a no-passing zone.

Another added that they were driving at 55 mph when Oster attempted to pass them, “going considerably faster,” the police report reads, and that Oster was trying to pass up to eight or 10 vehicles.

When a Honda Fit travelling east became visible, Oster reportedly attempted to get back into the westbound lane but struck a third car that was also going west. However, she reportedly struck a Subaru Outback in the westbound lane, and caused the Subaru to rotate into the eastbound lane, where the Honda T-boned it in the passenger side.

Jenna Rheuben, 32, of Seattle, and Kelly Nakata, 38, of Seattle and a dog were in the Honda; the two suffered major injuries and had to be flown to Harborview Medical Center in Seattle, and the dog was taken to an emergency vet.

Kim Davis Nordberg, 72, of Lakebay, and Bette Nordberg, 69, of Puyallup, in the Subaru, were dead when first responders arrived, and two dogs in their vehicle were also transported to an emergency vet.

The Enumclaw Fire Department, Buckley Fire Department, Kent-based Puget Sound Fire, Valley Regional Fire Authority and King County Medic One responded to the crash.

Oster was uninjured and was arrested on the scene.

She allegedly told troopers that the Subaru driver caused the accident by stepping on the breaks when she tried to merge back into the westbound lane; that she wasn’t speeding, “maybe a ‘little tiny bit, but not much’” and that other people told her she was “‘being safe’”; and that she was trying to get off of Dilaudid, an opioid pain medication.

Oster posted bond Oct. 14, according to King County jail records. Bail was set at $100,000 by the court at her Oct. 14 first appearance, according to the King County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office. Oster is scheduled to be arraigned at 9 a.m. Oct. 30 in the GA courtroom of the Maleng Regional Justice Center in Kent.


Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@kentreporter.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.kentreporter.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Northwest

A northern giant hornet seen on an apple. (Photo courtesy of Washington State Department of Agriculture)
Invasive ‘murder hornets’ found in WA have been eradicated

The hunt for invasive “murder hornets” is over in Washington and the… Continue reading

t
Second suspect arrested in Federal Way IHOP shooting death of 2-year-old

His DNA was reportedly found in the vehicle, and he is thought to be the driver.

t
Antique Marketplace in Auburn loses nearly $10,000 from theft

SEE THE VIDEO: The pair who allegedly carried out the theft had a toddler whom they used as a distraction.

King County District Court (pictured left to right): Judge Raul Martinez, Judge Corinna Harn, Judge Lisa Paglisotti, Judge Fa’amomoi Masaniai, Judge Kristin Shotwell, Judge Rebecca C. Robertson, Judge Peter Peaquin, Judge Jill Klinge, Judge Lisa O’Toole, Judge Kevin Peck, Judge Matthew York, Judge Leah Taguba, Judge Brian Todd, Judge Elizabeth D. Stephenson, Judge Kuljinder Dhillon, Judge Marcus Naylor, Judge Karama H. Hawkins, Judge Nathaniel Green. COURTESY PHOTO
Should Auburn restart its own municipal court?

City leaders are examining the cost and logistics behind current contract with King County.

Photos of Antonio Garcia-Fonseca. Courtesy of GoFundMe.
Federal Way man who shot teen in 2021 pleads guilty to manslaughter

The state recommends a sentence of nine years, six months

Several alternatives are being considered for the next stage of the link light rail linking Federal Way to the Tacoma Dome. These alternatives compare the possibilities for the segment of this section between Federal Way and Fife. Graphic provided by Sound Transit.
Public input sought for Federal Way to Tacoma Dome light rail route

Five options include routes along Interstate 5 or State Route 99. Public comment is open until Feb. 10, 2025.

Courtesy of the Renton Police Department.
24 chihuahuas seized from a Renton home

Many of the dogs were injured, and the home was dirty.

File photo
Glenfield Watkins.
Sexual assault victims file claims against Federal Way school district

The claims stem from former teacher Glenfield Watkins assault on student at Totem Middle School.

t
Auburn man charged with vehicular homicide in FW crash

Documents state his blood alcohol content was 0.132.

t
Auburn Police arrest man for investigation of multiple violent crimes

Detectives seize firearms and high-capacity magazines.

Screenshot of the lawsuit.
Lawsuit dismissed against Federal Way lawyer accused of fraud

The judge granted her motion to dismiss with prejudice, meaning the case is permanently dismissed

t
Charges upgraded for suspect in Federal Way hatchet attack

Noel Esteban, 72, died nearly eight months after being attacked