This security footage at the Cenex gas station in Black Diamond shows Anthony Chilcott on his phone before entering, and driving off with, Carl Sanders’ Ford Raptor and Monkey, his poodle, in the front seat.

This security footage at the Cenex gas station in Black Diamond shows Anthony Chilcott on his phone before entering, and driving off with, Carl Sanders’ Ford Raptor and Monkey, his poodle, in the front seat.

King County will review 2019 deputy killing of Black Diamond man

County Council members will be briefed Aug. 31 about the Sheriff’s Office handling of the case

King County will present a public review of the fatal 2019 deputy shooting of a Black Diamond man during a virtual meeting the morning of Tuesday, Aug. 31, the county council said in an Aug. 27 press release.

The King County Office of Law Enforcement Oversight, tasked with holding the King County Sheriff’s Office accountable, will deliver the presentation to the county council’s Law & Justice Committee, which is made up of six County Council members.

The review will center on the death of 36-year-old Anthony Chilcott, who was fatally shot by detectives George Alvarez and his partner Josh Lerum in November 2019.

Chilcott, deputies say, had stolen an unlocked truck several days before the shooting, prompting a “be on the lookout” law enforcement alert for him. Alvarez and Lerum found Chilcott on Nov. 25. When they confronted and tried to arrest Chilcott, who was in the truck, a struggle ensued in which both deputies fired their weapons at him.

This April, King County Sheriff Mitzi Johanknecht fired one of those detectives, George Alvarez, concluding the deputy’s tactics unnecessarily escalated that situation and likely risked the safety of himself, Lerum, and bystanders nearby. (Lerum was not fired but was reprimanded for not wearing a protective vest and raid jacket during the arrest attempt, a sheriff’s office representative told The Seattle Times.)

Neither Alvarez nor Lerum used excessive or unnecessary force when they shot and killed Chilcott, who could have struck and injured or killed the deputies while trying to drive away, the sheriff concluded. But Alvarez, who led the duo’s tactics in the encounter, should have waited for backup and surveilled Chilcott from a distance, rather than drive up next to him suddenly and escalate the situation, the sheriff found.

“The urgency here was created by your actions, not the actions of the suspect,” Johanknecht wrote in a March 25 notice of termination letter to Alvarez.

“Your actions demonstrated a disregard for the public, your partner and yourself,” she concluded.

Cooper Offenbecher, a Seattle attorney representing Alvarez, told the Seattle Times after the firing that Alvarez planned to challenge his termination. The deputy’s actions that day were necessary and justified due to the danger Chilcott posed to the community, Offenbecher told The Times.

The meeting this Tuesday will go over the Sheriff’s Office’s overall handling of the shooting.

It is scheduled to begin at 9:30 a.m. It will be streamed live and available on King County TV Channel 22 (Comcast Channel 22 and 322 HD).

Public comment can be sent to kcccomitt@kingcounty.gov, or by visiting https://kingcounty.gov/council/committees/law_justice.aspx. Comments submitted before by 8 a.m. on the day of the meeting will be distributed to staff and council members prior to the meeting.

Comments can also be delivered orally by joining the meeting via Zoom. The meeting ID will be 997 4560 2933, and the password will be 210362, according to the press release.

The County Council’s Law & Justice Committee is chaired by Girmay Zahilay and vice chaired by Kathy Lambert. Its members also include Claudia Balducci, Rod Dembowski, Jeanne Kohl-Welles, and District 9 representative Reagan Dunn.


Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@kentreporter.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.kentreporter.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Northwest

Photo by Joshua Solorzano/Auburn Reporter
Jeffrey Nelson, at his hearing Dec. 20, listening to the judge decide whether there will be a new trial and judge recusal.
Judge denies retrial for ex-Auburn police officer convicted of murder

Judge Phelps said that Jeffrey Nelson’s arguments were not persuasive; sentencing set for Jan 23, 2025.

Mt. Rainier National Park has around 2 million visitors a year. Image courtesy the National Park Service
The mountain is out and it tells cold deadly tales

Data shows that since 2007, Mt. Rainier has become the second most dangerous National Park in the winter.

Screenshot
Federal judge sentences bikini barista chain owner for tax evasion

LadyBug Espresso has locations in Kent, Auburn, Renton and other cities; failed to report $6M in revenue

A northern giant hornet seen on an apple. (Photo courtesy of Washington State Department of Agriculture)
Invasive ‘murder hornets’ found in WA have been eradicated

The hunt for invasive “murder hornets” is over in Washington and the… Continue reading

t
Second suspect arrested in Federal Way IHOP shooting death of 2-year-old

His DNA was reportedly found in the vehicle, and he is thought to be the driver.

t
Antique Marketplace in Auburn loses nearly $10,000 from theft

SEE THE VIDEO: The pair who allegedly carried out the theft had a toddler whom they used as a distraction.

King County District Court (pictured left to right): Judge Raul Martinez, Judge Corinna Harn, Judge Lisa Paglisotti, Judge Fa’amomoi Masaniai, Judge Kristin Shotwell, Judge Rebecca C. Robertson, Judge Peter Peaquin, Judge Jill Klinge, Judge Lisa O’Toole, Judge Kevin Peck, Judge Matthew York, Judge Leah Taguba, Judge Brian Todd, Judge Elizabeth D. Stephenson, Judge Kuljinder Dhillon, Judge Marcus Naylor, Judge Karama H. Hawkins, Judge Nathaniel Green. COURTESY PHOTO
Should Auburn restart its own municipal court?

City leaders are examining the cost and logistics behind current contract with King County.

Photos of Antonio Garcia-Fonseca. Courtesy of GoFundMe.
Federal Way man who shot teen in 2021 pleads guilty to manslaughter

The state recommends a sentence of nine years, six months

Several alternatives are being considered for the next stage of the link light rail linking Federal Way to the Tacoma Dome. These alternatives compare the possibilities for the segment of this section between Federal Way and Fife. Graphic provided by Sound Transit.
Public input sought for Federal Way to Tacoma Dome light rail route

Five options include routes along Interstate 5 or State Route 99. Public comment is open until Feb. 10, 2025.

Courtesy of the Renton Police Department.
24 chihuahuas seized from a Renton home

Many of the dogs were injured, and the home was dirty.

File photo
Glenfield Watkins.
Sexual assault victims file claims against Federal Way school district

The claims stem from former teacher Glenfield Watkins assault on student at Totem Middle School.

t
Auburn man charged with vehicular homicide in FW crash

Documents state his blood alcohol content was 0.132.